Many A/E firm leaders lament the shortage of capable professionals in
the design industry. While the shortage of design professionals, especially
in certain specialties, is real, many firms make the hiring process more
difficult by restricting their recruiting of women.
Although it's illegal to discriminate on the basis of gender when hiring,
and things have improved for women over the years, there is still a bias
against women in some A/E firms. This attitude is counterproductive, especially
over the long run. Firms that discriminate against women reduce their pool
of potential employees, yet some firms continue to screen out women candidates
during recruiting, even when they are in desperate need of additional staff.
While women sometimes present managers with challenges as they go through
their child-raising years, it is well worth the effort to hire them and
integrate them into the workforce, says Lynn S. Miggins, P.E., the majority
owner and president of KS Associates in Akron, OH. Miggins, who has 30
years in the engineering profession, herself went through the same professional
and work/life challenges that
women experience today. She has taken what she's learned and applied it
to her firm to make the workplace climate amenable to women. Her 50-person
civil engineering and land surveying firm's workforce is composed of about
25% women, significantly higher than the industry average of less than
10%.
As many women decide to take a few years off, or at least reduce their
work hours, in order to raise children, firms that want to retain them
have to make adjustments for their needs. "A lot of women drop out
of the industry when entering their child-raising years," Miggins
says. As a result, they aren't able to keep up with technological changes
and lose contacts with clients. "We have to keep them engaged during
their child-raising years," Miggins says. "That's a problem
I'm trying to address in my firm."
KS Associates offers flex-time and part-time schedules to accommodate
working mothers. Flexible and part-time hours create scheduling challenges
for managers, Miggins acknowledges. A key to making non-traditional work
schedules successful, she says, is to negotiate hours in advance and
make sure both managers and employees are committed to sticking to the
schedule. Miggins works out 30-day schedules in advance to accommodate
her part-time workers.
Some women employees that work part-time actually make better use of
their work hours than other employees, Miggins says. Their
productivity is high because they know that their family commitments
require them to be masters of their schedules. Every minute is precious
because they have so many things to do outside of work, leaving little
time to waste both on and off the job.
Many top managers at other firms agree in principle with Miggins's overall
strategy in accommodating the needs of women in the workplace. Unfortunately,
some of those firms do not want to actually make the effort to change
their policies.
"I have a colleague who was with another firm, and when she had
a child she asked to go to more of a part time schedule," Miggins
says. "The firm agreed, but undermined her success by scheduling
staff meetings on days that she was off. She began to feel like she had
been demoted. Her firm paid lip service to a flex schedule, but did not
really provide the support that she needed."
Even when top managers decide to try some flex scheduling,
Miggins points out, unless there is full support for the plan at lower
managerial levels, the initiative will fail. There has to be full commitment
from the entire organization, and likely, a strong effort to change the
established culture.
Is this effort worth it? It is, particularly if you realize that your
firm is better off with able part-time contributors rather than being
without them altogether. Also, keep in mind that as the children of part
time mothers grow up, some of these part-timers will want to increase
their hours, eventually returning to a full-time role. Think of this
as building your bench for the long term.
What do you think? Let us know...
Justin Roy is a Principal with SullivanKreiss. He can
be reached at jroy@sullivankreiss.com .
Did you
know that...
- Less than two percent of high school graduates will earn engineering
degrees?
- Colleges and universities are having difficulty recruiting
women engineering students?
- Today, just 20 percent of undergraduate
engineering students are women?
- Even more astounding is the number of women engineers in the professional
workforce - less than ten percent!
John Kreiss to Speak at AIA Virginia
John Kreiss, President of SullivanKreiss, is scheduled to speak at the AIA
Virginia Conference on November 18, 2007. John will be speaking about
leadership in the industry.
SullivanKreiss Offers New Service
In response to the A/E industry recruiting and staffing demands, SullivanKreiss
has officially added a staffing division to their services. These arrangements
are designed for those firms who are looking to take a proactive approach
to their recruiting needs.
To learn more about this service, please contact:
Justin Roy at 312-893-5058, or e-mail
him.
2008 A/E Advisors Annual CEO Forums
A/E Advisors will be hosting
two CEO Forums in 2008 - one exclusively for large-firm CEOs (March 5
- 7) and one for CEOs of smaller firms of 150 or fewer employees (March
3 - 5). Please mark your calendar and stay tuned for more information,
or email John Kreiss.
|